2019 Brunello di Montalcino, Sugarille, Pieve di Santa Restituta, Gaja, Tuscany, Italy

To complete Angelo Gaja’s comparison with his Langhe wines, he likens Sugarille to Barolo (as opposed to the Rennina, which he equates with Barbaresco). Powerfully constructed, this will appeal to drinkers seeking a vigorous style of Brunello. Sweet oak spice and plum take on earthy forest undertones. It's ample and expansive in fruit, yet austere and tight in structure: dark cherry and plum hang off steely, vertical grape tannins. Thicker wood tannins build through the core but crisp acidity offsets the dense structure, and medicinal herbs are tucked into its layers. This becomes increasingly firmer as it sits in the glass, and will need a whole lot of time.Drink 2027 - 2039Michaela Morris, Decanter.com (November 2023)

The 2019 Brunello di Montalcino Sugarille is dark and youthfully inward, forcing the taster to work with its brooding blend of blackberries, sage and crushed stone. This displays textures of pure silk, polished and refined, with a dense textural wave of tart red and black fruits underscored by saline minerals and exotic spice. Orange notes add contrast through the close as this finishes tannic and long, with a pleasantly chewy sensation and angular tannins that pinch the cheeks. The 2019 is a dark stallion of a Brunello, all muscle and meat, that will take many years of cellaring to show its best. That said, it will be worth the wait.Drink 2026 - 2040eric_guido, Vinous.com.com (November 2023)

The Pieve Santa Restituta 2019 Brunello di Montalcino Sugarille reveals a finely chiseled quality, with direct and lifted fruit, that gives this wine an angular or delineated personality. This impression is reinforced by delicate mineral notes of crushed stone that fold into dark fruit, sweet plum, black cherry and earthy iris root. The wine is elegant, but it also shows lots of umami or textural deliciousness thanks to the natural ripeness and concentration of the fruit. Give this wine more time in bottle.Drink 2026 - 2045monica_larner, Wine Advocate (December 2023)

Extremely perfumed and intense with lilacs, violets, purple fruits and black cherries. Full-bodied and very structured with punchy tannins that give this great length and intensity. This is a great one for the cellar.Try after 2027james_suckling, jamessuckling_com (January 2024)

Mid to deep ruby with orange tinges. Much more closed and slumbering than the Rennina and with an undertow of oak. There is also a little more stuffing. Backward on the palate, with gorgeous cherry, cranberry and raspberry fruit. Super-fine, deep tannins. Polished and long and with a tannic bite on the finish.Drink 2026 - 2040Walter Speller, JancisRobinson.com (October 2023)